Tag Archives: sex work

Rest in Power: Margo St. James

announcement of a May 1, 2021 memorial for Margo St. JamesLaurie and Debbie say:

Margo St. James died in January 2021, after leading a remarkable life. She fought the uphill battle of decriminalizing sex work and recognizing women’s (and all adults’) rights to choose prostitution, as well as other forms of sex work. She began her tireless advocacy for women’s rights to our own bodies in 1972, when she held gatherings of the cleverly named WHOM — Whores, Housewives, and Other Mothers.

She is best known for COYOTE — Call Off Your Old Tired Ethics. Clearly, she had a gift for naming organizations. COYOTE was one of the founding resources for the St. James Infirmary, an active San Francisco “peer-based occupational health and safety clinic for sex workers of all genders.” The bio of Margo St. James on the SJI site says:

She said that she founded COYOTE in response to police treatment of prostitutes and to feminists’ contempt for them. At the time she founded COYOTE, she was in touch with the English Collective of Prostitutes and with Selma James, who’d recently founded Wages for Housework. Flo Kennedy, a black feminist lawyer and founder of the Feminist Party, who Margo said taught her to “kick-ass and “did the most to turn me out” (clearly meaning inspiring Margo as a political activist) and was a very early decrim advocate who explained that, “I just don’t see that women have such fascinating jobs, for the most part, that a job that pays ten times as much as most others should be outlawed.” [book: Color me Flo]

St. James’ name became synonymous with the cause now known as “decrim.”

COYOTE gave legal help to sex workers, published COYOTE HOWLS newspaper to over 60,000 subscribers, and successfully fought to overturn city policies. She attended national and international women’s conferences, testified, and lectured. She pushed decriminalization onto the political agenda and led an international movement to decriminalize sex work.

She ran for a supervisor position in San Francisco, endorsed by the Mayor, but didn’t win. She convinced Cecil Williams, a prominent San Francisco clergyman, to host the annual Hookers’ Ball. The Atlantic Monthly published a feature on her, saying “no public relations expert could do more for prostitutes than Margo St. James has done with COYOTE.”

Mary Reinholz, writing at The Village Sun, draws a direct line from St. James herself to the people continuing her work today.

History repeats itself. St. James was always a controversial figure in the feminism of her time. She may have had Flo Kennedy and many others aligned with her, but she also faced a great deal of “feminist” opposition from the faction that believes that all prostitution is exploitation, and all women who sell their bodies are forced to do so.

Today, the National Organization for Women still opposes decrim, and specifically a 2019 bill in the New York State legislature. The current executive director of NOW-NYC is quoted as saying:

“When the sex trade is decriminalized, demand increases, and in an unregulated market, predatory men who pay to have sex with poor women become law-abiding citizens. That’s not progress, it’s doubling down on male privilege.” However, due in no small part to the movement Margo St. James embodied, even NOW-NYC and Gloria Steinem, support a bill which would decriminalize prostitution, but keep laws against pimps, brothels, and “related sex trade operatives.”

Men who pay to have sex with poor women are effectively “law-abiding citizens” now, and have been so for longer than St. James was working to change hearts, minds, and laws. Men are not prosecuted for paying for sex work. In addition, although NOW-NYC didn’t bring up the specter of human trafficking and child endangerment in this quotation, many opponents of decrim use that argument, even though they know we could erase every law against prostitution off the books tomorrow, and there would still be a robust body of law protecting children and anyone under age in any state from exploitation, grooming, and victimization. Margo St. James was a crusader for the rights of adults, mostly women, to do what each of us chooses to do with our own bodies–and have the opportunity to use the laws to help them stay healthy, safe, and out of jail.

We remember her as the hero she was.

Follow Debbie on Twitter.

Follow Laurie’s new Pandemic Shadows photos on Instagram.

Links for a New Year

Debbie says:

I spent the last two weeks of the old year, and the first week of this one, harvesting so many links I can’t blog them all. Here’s a selection of especially interesting ones.

jaden and three female models, all in skirts, with handbags

Gender fluidity crossed a major barrier very recently. Jaden Smith will be modeling traditionally female clothes for Louis Vuitton. John Boone at ET says,

Jaden dons a skirt and fringed top in the fashion line’s Spring 2016 campaign and poses alongside models Sarah Brannon, Rianne Van Rompaey, and Jean Campbell. Nicolas Ghesquière, creative director of Louis Vuitton, was first to share the photos, writing, “Happy to introduce Jaden Smith.”

Women have been wearing various kinds of traditionally male clothing, from slacks to tuxedos, both inside and outside the fashion industry for decades. But a male-bodied person in a skirt is still a surprise in most contexts (though on a cold-for-California day in December I saw a tall, thin, bearded guy in a gauzy just-below-the-knee skirt, bare legs and sandals, holding a toddler’s hand; made me happy all day).

***

The fashion industry’s choices aren’t going to solve the problems of trans teens. Claudia McNeilly writes at Broadly about young trans people and eating disorders, something I certainly knew nothing about:

A study published in the Journal of Adolescent Health earlier this year found that transgender youth were four times more likely to report an eating disorder diagnosis than their cisgender heterosexual female peers—the next leading eating disorder group. …

The researchers compared various gender identity and sexual orientation groups with cisgender heterosexual women, who are usually the focus of eating disorder literature. Not only were transgender students four times more likely to report an eating disorder diagnosis than their cisgender heterosexual female peers, they were also twice as likely to report using diet pills and more than twice as likely to report vomiting or laxative use during the previous month.

McNeilly looks at stresses on transgender teens from a few perspectives, with a great conclusion:

In order to seriously address the issue of eating disorders among trans youth, it seems, the simplest way is to shift our understanding of what eating disorders look like and whom they affect. Dr. Alexis Duncan, senior author of the study [said]: “People tend to think about eating disorders as being people with anorexia, but most people with eating disorders are not too thin, so they by definition do not have anorexia. It’s much more likely that someone will have binge eating disorder or bulimia, and be of normal weight or even overweight. So the question is: how do we bust the myth?”

***

It’s not eating disorders, but you might call it overly ordered eating. Kate Handley, writing at Sociological Images, has studied how our companions affect how we eat:

For my senior thesis, I explored whether women change the way they eat  alongside what they eat when dining with a male vs. female companion. The study is small, and intentionally limited to Euro-American women. I found it interesting and completely unsurprising.

I found that women did change the way they ate depending on the gender of their dining companion. Overall, when dining with a male companion, women typically constructed their bites carefully, took small bites, ate slowly, used their napkins precisely and frequently, and maintained good posture and limited body movement throughout their meals. In contrast, women dining with a female companion generally constructed their bites more haphazardly, took larger bites, used their napkins more loosely and sparingly, and moved their bodies more throughout their meals.

***

Men may or may not be judging how the women with them eat; Handley didn’t examine that. But we learned that at the highest levels of government and politics, men are judging how and where and when and for how long women pee. After Hillary Clinton was frequently and publicly criticized for missing a few minutes of debate because of a long bathroom line, Soraya Chemaly wrote this for the Huffington Post:

I write and talk about controversial subjects all the time – violence, rape, race – but I have never received as vitriolic a response as last summer, when I wrote about the disparity in public facilities for men and women, The Everyday Sexism of Women Waiting in Bathroom Lines; it was a piece about norms and knowledge.  Angry people mostly men, by the hundreds, wrote to tell me I was vulgar, stupid, ignorant and should learn to stand in order to pee, because it’s superior. It continued for weeks, until I wrote a follow-up piece on the ten most sexist responses.

… Can you imagine the backlash and media frenzy if Clinton had actually, in some detail, pointed out that the women’s room was farther away or that there is often, especially at large public events like this debate, a line that women patiently wait in while men flit in and out and makes jokes about women’s vanity? That the microaggressive hostility evident, structurally, in so many of our legacy public spaces is relevant to women every day. “Bathroom codes enforce archaic and institutionalized gender norms,” wrote Princeton students Monica Shi & Amanda Shi about their school’s systemic sexism this year.

***

If you’re curious about Addyi (the “female Viagra”), you’ll appreciate Amy Gamerman’s long, detailed article for Vogue on her experiences with it, plus some scientific background and information about what else is coming down the pike for pharmacology and women’s desire. Gamerman’s piece is hard to excerpt, but here’s a bit that caught my eye:

My desire is improving, as is the quality of the sex. I’m more enthusiastic, less distracted. The color commentary that usually runs through my mind during the act—This is nice, but am I enjoying it enough? Is that a paint chip on the ceiling?—has fallen silent. The sharp edges of daily life melt, just a bit.

Has the Addyi flipped a switch in my entorhinal cortex? More likely, the drug is helping to create “a good neurochemical environment” for desire, according to Jim Pfaus, Ph.D., a scientist in the pharmacology of sex, based at Montreal’s Concordia University. Mindfulness training, sensate exercises, and talk therapy could probably achieve the same result, given enough time and energy. But as Pfaus points out, “You can’t take a trip to Cozumel every weekend.”

Gamerman decided to renew her prescription. I wonder what else the Addyi is doing, and whether she’s missing other benefits to that theoretical trip to Cozumel. At the same time, she provides an interesting counterpoint to this link I posted last year.

***

Finally, Margaret Corvid, writing for The Establishment, tells us what sex work has taught her about self-employment. Here’s one example.

Your time and emotional labor are worth money.

The work you’re paid to do is rarely all the work you do to keep your job. If you’re paid to code as part of a team, you’re probably not paid to make yourself presentable and business appropriate, deal with catcalling and packed subway cars on the way to work, and silently bear the racist rants of your office’s resident Trump fan.

The same holds true if you run your own business, but with the advantage that you can, like a magician, convert bullshit into money. If a client wants to book me in the kink studio three hours away across a rat’s nest of traffic-snarled roads, he’s going to be paying a premium for my mileage, time, pain, and suffering—and he’ll get a better service from me when I feel adequately compensated, rather than resentful. If a client wants to talk about the dirty details with me over the phone while jerking off, he’s either going to pay me or I’ll hang up and append “wanker” to his name in my phone.

It’s rare and refreshing to see sex work analyzed as work rather than as sex.

All links from my regular reading, which includes Feministe, Feministing, Shakesville, Sociological Images, and io9, among other sites.