Tag Archives: immigration

“Anchor Babies”: Where are the Real Children?

Laurie and Debbie say:

Maegan La Mala at Vivirlatino has a short and powerful rant about “anchor babies”:

… how women of color, women like me and so many of my hermanas and vecinas, are being talked about instead of talked with or listened to. How our wombs are worded as weapons of mass destruction and our beautiful babies as objects stuck into the earth to keep us here. This dehumanization of some Latina mujeres cuerpos (because let’s keep it real, not all mujer Latina cuerpos can/will have babies pero they still are mujer Latina bodies) and the life that comes from those bodies is what allows hate crimes to go unpunished, what allows the separation of mother from child to be ok, and what allows violence against immigrant mujeres to be ignored.

… this comes down to where ethnicity and gender meet. That now Latina mujer = anchor baby factory.

If you’re not caught up with this particular piece of lunacy, some members of the Republican party (including Senator Lindsay Graham from South Carolina and Senator John Kyl from Georgia) are seriously calling for the repeal of the Fourteenth Amendment, which provides that children born in the U.S. are U.S. citizens. The amendment was drafted to make former slaves into citizens, and it also provides citizenship to the children born in the United States whose parents are not citizens.

“Anchor babies” is the catchword of the movement to repeal this amendment. It’s defined as Latina immigrants having babies (often referred to by those opposed to automatic citizenship as “dropping” babies) for the purpose of securing their place in the United States. These babies, so the argument goes, are being conceived and born for the wealth of social services and support they receive in the U.S., and to help their parents fight deportation attempts.

It’s painful even to have to repeat the truth: most parents, regardless of race, economic status, or citizenship, love their babies and their children. If an illegal immigrant really wants to stay in the United States, there are cheaper and less demanding ways to try to become a citizen. People have kids where they live, where their lives are centered.

Of course, the issue isn’t about babies. Politicians may kiss babies, but (as a group) they put their agendas and their careers ahead of the needs of real babies and children. They just use babies as symbols for whatever causes they either believe in or think will get them re-elected. Most often, the dehumanized babies and children are white, and are used as objects we must protect:

We can’t have gay marriage, because our children will be exposed to the evil of gayness. (Translation: I believe gayness is evil.) We can’t let our children be exposed to Hallowe’en celebrations, because that’s Satanism. (Translation: Witches threaten my religious beliefs.)

The “anchor baby” catch phrase is the opposite side of the same coin, using brown babies and children as fear objects: we can’t have brown babies and children getting services in our hospitals and schools because then they will overrun us and bankrupt us. (Translation: I don’t want to live a world in which most people aren’t white.)

The “anchor baby” almost certainly can’t repeal the amendment. Nonetheless, if they make much headway they can still endanger a lot of individual lives of real babies and children and mothers and fathers.

It’s no coincidence that all of these uses of babies as devices come from the same people who vehemently oppose the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, which the United States has not endorsed … because they’re not interested in supporting laws that outlaw violence against children, and the abuse of children.

Maegan at Vivirlatino knows about the real children who are endangered by this movement:

What I worry about, as this rhetoric keeps building, is what about the babies, the children. How can we guarantee their safety?

Thanksgiving 2009

Laurie and Debbie say:

There’s no doubt that 2009 has been a difficult year, but it still has a lot to celebrate, appreciate, and be thankful for.

Last year, we said “We have a sane man coming in to the American presidency. We have a smart man coming into the American presidency. We have the first African-American to come into the American presidency. (And they’re all the same person!)” And now he’s president, and he’s been president for nine months. There’s an African-American family living in the White House. That’s huge.

The movement that elected Obama hasn’t given up. Progressive groups like Move On!, People for the American Way, and many others are applying real pressure on elected officials, often cleverly. We’re particularly impressed with the Health Care Accountability Pledge, which is collecting promises for money to defeat any Democrat who “keeps health care reform from getting an up or down vote.”

It’s pressure like that that made it possible, even with the insurance companies funding enormous opposition, to get a health care bill passed in the House … and to get cloture on debate on a health care bill (without the nasty anti-abortion provision) in the Senate. Plenty of hurdles left, but we’ve crossed two where they wanted to stop us for good.

Kimberly Clark, world’s largest producer of tissues, has bowed to environmentalists’ pressure and is using sustainable forest management techniques, leading the way for other paper companies to do the same. And on a similar note, Bertin, world’s largest leather manufacturer, is not buying cattle from farms responsible for Amazon deforestation.

The Obama administration is trying at least some Guantanamo prison “detainees” in U.S. civilian courts! After as much as eight years of being confined and tortured without representation or protections, this is a small step in a crucial direction.

After twenty years of a shameful policy preventing people with AIDS from traveling to the United States, the Obama Administration has lifted the ban. Starting very early in 2010, your HIV status will not affect your right to visit the United States. It’s not about time, it’s long past time, but it is happening.

After an extraordinary battery of gender tests, Caster Semenya will be allowed to keep her gold medal and her prize money. We blogged about this story here.

The CIA is not immune any more. A trial in Milan, Italy, resulted in the conviction of 22 alleged CIA officers and agents, an American air force colonel and two Italian agents, who were convicted of kidnapping an Egyptian cleric from a Milan street in 2003.

Speaking of successful political pressure from progressives, Presente led a successful campaign to get racist, virulently anti-immigrant CNN anchor Lou Dobbs off the airwaves and . More than 100,000 people signed the petition, and Dobbs resigned “to take a more activist role” and is now talking about the Senate, and also the Presidency in 2012. Imagine the entertainment value of a Palin/Dobbs (or Dobbs/Palin) ticket!

Have a great holiday! We’ll be back early next week, when we’ll do a crosspost to the fabulous FWD.